Section 14a · Grid fees
Section 14a: module 1, 2 or 3?
Flat rate, reduced energy price or time windows – calculated with the 2026 price sheet.
Read the article →Technical article · Section 14a EnWG · Existing systems
Since 2024, grid-oriented control has applied to new heat pumps and wallboxes in Germany. But what about the heat pump installed back in 2019 – with its own meter and a cheap heat pump tariff? The Federal Network Agency's determination distinguishes three cases, and the case is decided not by the year of installation alone but by a question many cannot answer. This page explains it – with the wording of the transitional provisions.
The transitional provisions are in item 10 of determination BK6-22-300. They are not tied to a contract but to a fact: whether a reduced grid fee under section 14a was granted for the system until the end of 2023. That is no accident. The Federal Network Agency explains:
“Among other things following a note from N-ERGIE Netz GmbH that in practice no concrete individual (written) agreements under section 14a EnWG (old version) had in some cases been concluded, the determination for clarification no longer refers to the existence of an agreement, but rather to the fact of whether a corresponding grid fee reduction was actually granted.”
In practice you check this on your electricity bill: if the heat pump runs on its own meter with a reduced grid fee – often called a heat pump or heating electricity tariff – the answer is, as a rule, yes. If in doubt, ask the grid operator; it knows what it has billed.
| Case | What applies | Reference |
|---|---|---|
| In operation before 2024, reduced grid fee granted | old rules continue “unchanged until 31.12.2028 at the latest” | item 10.1 |
| In operation before 2024, no reduced grid fee | “this determination does not apply” | item 10.3 |
| Night storage heater | old rules until they end or the device is decommissioned | item 10.2 b |
Case 1 is the most common: the heat pump with a heat pump tariff. For it, nothing changes until the end of 2028 as long as the operator changes nothing.
Case 2 concerns systems whose operators previously decided against control – such as a heat pump on the normal household meter. The Federal Network Agency expressly exempts them from the obligation “for reasons of legitimate expectations”. This also applies to a later extension: such old systems are not counted when adding up controllable devices behind a grid connection.
Case 3, the night storage heater, stays with the old arrangement permanently. “With the replacement, substitution or conversion of the installation, however, this grandfathering ends.”
For case 1, the transition period ends with 2028 at the latest. What applies then depends, under item 10.2, on what the system is:
The grid fee itself is frozen until then too: under grid fee determination BK8-22/010-A, the grid operator continues to bill according to the previous procedure during the transition, based “on the percentage of the energy price reduction and a standing charge reduction of the year 2023”.
The difference that matters most in everyday life: under the new rules, the grid operator may no longer switch off. The Federal Network Agency: “Complete shutdowns of controllable devices are no longer permitted.” Consumption may fall to as little as 4.2 kW during an intervention, and only when a specific overload threatens.
Nobody has to wait until 2029. Item 10.4 of the determination:
“Operators of a controllable device under item 10.2.a. and item 10.3. may switch at any time at their own request to grid-oriented control in accordance with this determination. The grid operator cannot refuse the switch. A renewed switch back to an arrangement under section 14a (2) sentence 1 EnWG or the corresponding predecessor arrangement is not possible.”
Three things follow:
With the switch, the operator also takes on the obligations of the new arrangement: under item 4.6 it must “ensure that the controllable device is equipped with the necessary technical equipment including control devices and is always controllable”. For an older system, that can mean work in the meter cabinet – what is needed there is covered in Control box in an old meter cabinet.
Netze BW's 2026 price sheet shows both worlds side by side – a rare stroke of luck for the comparison. For a heat pump with its own meter:
| Old: existing with agreement | New: module 2 | |
|---|---|---|
| Energy price | 5.62 ct/kWh | 3.61 ct/kWh |
| Standing charge | none shown | none |
| at 5,000 kWh a year | €281.00 | €180.50 |
In Netze BW's grid area, the new module 2 is therefore cheaper on the grid fee than the old heat pump tariff – around 100 euros a year at 5,000 kWh. On top of that, the new rules no longer allow switching off.
Even so, this is not an automatic recommendation. Three questions need answering before switching: What does the technology cost to make the system controllable under the new determination? What does the electricity supplier do – does it pass the reduction on, and does the tariff change? And: the switch is final. With other grid operators the calculation can look entirely different; the figures above apply only to Netze BW's grid area.
One last transitional rule does not concern old systems but new devices that technically cannot be controlled. Item 10.6 exempts controllable devices from the control requirements (items 3 to 5)
All three conditions must be met together. The determination does not specify in detail what the proof must look like – that is clarified with the grid operator before commissioning. And the deadline is close: from 2027 this exception no longer exists for newly commissioned devices.
That depends on whether a reduced grid fee was billed for it until the end of 2023. If so, the old rules continue until 31 December 2028 at the latest, after which the new determination applies. If not, the new determination does not apply to this system at all and there is no obligation. What matters is not whether a written contract exists but whether the reduction was actually granted.
For existing systems that have so far received a reduced grid fee, the old rules end at the latest then. If the system is a controllable device within the meaning of the determination, i.e. above 4.2 kW, the new requirements including the grid fee modules apply from then on. If it is below that, it drops out of section 14a and no longer receives a reduction. Night storage heaters are exempt.
Yes, at any time, and the grid operator cannot refuse. This also applies to systems that have so far had no reduced grid fee at all. The switch is final, however: returning to the old arrangement is expressly excluded.
Not under the new rules. The Federal Network Agency states that complete shutdowns of controllable devices are no longer permitted. Consumption may be reduced to as little as 4.2 kW during an intervention. As long as an existing system runs under the old rules, the control arrangement agreed there continues, until the end of 2028 at the latest.
Item 10.6 of the determination exempts controllable devices from the control obligations if they demonstrably cannot be controlled technically, if controllability cannot be established with reasonable technical effort either, and if they are commissioned by the end of 31 December 2026. The determination does not specify in detail how this is to be proven; that is clarified with the grid operator.
All information comes from the following documents, each with the date it was checked. All sources are in German.
This article is not legal advice. The responsible grid operator can say bindingly which case applies to a system.
Considering bringing an older heat pump into the new arrangement and want to know beforehand what the meter cabinet will need? Write to me – the initial consultation is free.