Technical article

When the funding rules choose the technology

A municipality plans a wood-fired boiler for its heat network. In the end none is built – not because it would be technically unsuitable, but because the funding conditions rule it out. How that comes about can be followed in the rules of Germany's efficient heat networks programme.

Programme
BEW – German federal funding for efficient heat networks
Case study
Ilsfeld heat network, transformation plan 2025
Figures as of
September 2026
Author
Julian Haag, state-certified electrical engineering technician

The four modules

The programme does not simply fund "heat networks" but four clearly separated things. Knowing the split also explains why projects run in this order.

The four modules of Germany's efficient heat networks funding Module 1 funds transformation plans and feasibility studies and is split into two stages. Module 2 funds new networks and the transformation of existing ones supplied at least 75 per cent from renewables and waste heat. Module 3 funds individual measures in existing networks. Module 4 funds ongoing operating costs for solar thermal plant and electric heat pumps feeding into networks. Module 1 transformation plan, feasibility study stage 1: the plan stage 2: design work Module 2 new build and transformation at least 75 % from renewables, waste heat Module 3 individual measures in existing networks efficiency and renewable integration Module 4 operating costs per kWh produced solar thermal and heat pumps plan first then build or retrofit then operate The modules build on each other: no funded plan, no funded implementation. Module 4 is the only one that keeps paying, because it is paid per kilowatt-hour produced.
Own diagram, following the municipality's description of the modules.

Module 1 funds the thinking before the building: transformation plans and feasibility studies aimed at greenhouse gas neutrality by 2045. It comes in two stages – stage 1 is the plan itself, stage 2 covers the design work that follows. In this case the transformation plan was funded at 50 per cent.

Module 2 is the systemic funding for new networks and the transformation of existing ones – on condition that the network is supplied at least 75 per cent from renewables and waste heat.

Module 3 funds individual measures in existing networks: efficiency improvements and the integration of renewables, without rebuilding the whole network.

Module 4 is the most unusual. It funds not the investment but the ongoing operation – a payment per kilowatt-hour produced by solar thermal plant and electric heat pumps feeding into a heat network.

Why operating cost support makes the difference

A heat pump has a basic disadvantage against a boiler: it is expensive to buy and its running cost depends on the electricity price. Investment support addresses the first problem and leaves the second open – and it is the second that decides over twenty years of operation.

How strongly that works shows in the case study's economic calculation. Specific heat generation costs for four expansion stages were calculated both with and without operating cost support:

Specific heat generation cost by expansion stage
Expansion stagewith operating supportwithout
Densification plus wastewater heat pump13.6 ct/kWh15.6 ct/kWh
plus expansion to Ilsfeld Ost13.0 ct/kWh15.5 ct/kWh
plus Obere Bustadt12.8 ct/kWh15.3 ct/kWh
plus Auenstein Ost13.1 ct/kWh15.8 ct/kWh

The difference is two to two and a half cents per kilowatt-hour – against a target blended price of 17.5 ct/kWh that is a good twelve to fourteen per cent. Without this support the arithmetic shifts far enough that a heat pump solution would be considerably harder to justify against a gas boiler.

That is the programme's real lever. Investment grants exist elsewhere too; support that flows for twenty years per kilowatt-hour produced fundamentally changes the economics of a plant – and is what allows a large heat pump to compete with a boiler at all.

The case where the directive dictated the technology

Now to the most interesting part. The programme limits how much biomass a funded network may use:

The reasoning is defensible in energy policy terms: wood and biogas are available only in limited quantities, and a heat network burning mostly biomass permanently ties up a scarce resource that is harder to substitute elsewhere.

In the case study this rule meets a network that already relies heavily on biomass. The balance at 60 per cent densification without further additions looks like this:

Generation balance of the example network at 60 % densification
GeneratorHeatShare
Biogas CHP unit4,221,000 kWh25.9 %
Pellet boilers2,738,000 kWh16.8 %
Heat pumps 1 and 23,649,000 kWh22.4 %
Natural gas CHP units3,279,000 kWh20.2 %
Boilers2,413,000 kWh14.8 %
Total16,300,000 kWh100 %

Biogas and pellets together come to 42.7 per cent – well above the 25 per cent cap and above the 35 per cent allowed during the approval period.

The consequence is stated unambiguously in the transformation plan: with a network length of over 20 kilometres and the biomass share already reached, the funding directive permits no further addition of biomass-based generation. The wood-fired boiler originally planned at the treatment plant site was therefore not pursued further.

For the expansion, that left essentially only heat pumps. This is not a judgement but an observation: a funding directive is not merely a financing instrument, it is technology policy. Whoever takes it up adopts its priorities – here: ambient heat before combustion, even where combustion would be technically simpler.

The route back below the cap does not run only through new generators, incidentally. With the first package of measures – densification to a 70 per cent connection rate plus an additional wastewater heat pump – the biomass share falls to 31.8 per cent and the renewable share rises to 88.7 per cent. More customers on the existing pipe therefore also shift eligibility for funding.

What this means in practice

Three transferable points follow from the case:

Frequently asked questions

What is the BEW programme?

Germany's federal funding for efficient heat networks. It supports the construction and transformation of heat networks through four modules: planning, systemic network construction, individual measures in existing networks, and operating cost support for solar thermal plant and heat pumps.

What is the module 4 operating cost support?

A payment per kilowatt-hour produced by solar thermal plant and electric heat pumps feeding into a heat network. Unlike an investment grant it works across the whole operating life. In the case considered here it lowers specific heat generation costs by two to two and a half cents per kilowatt-hour.

How much biomass may a funded heat network use?

At most 25 per cent of heat supplied, to be reached by 2045; until the end of the approval period of the first package of measures a cap of 35 per cent applies. Networks already above that share may not add further biomass generators.

Why was no wood-fired boiler built in the example?

Because network length and the biomass share already reached meant the funding directive permitted no further biomass generators. At 42.7 per cent the share was well above the cap. That left heat pumps for the expansion.

Can the biomass share fall without new plant?

Yes. Since it is a percentage share of heat supplied, it falls when other generators deliver more or when more heat is sold overall. In the example it drops from 42.7 to 31.8 per cent through densification and one additional heat pump.

Sources

Module descriptions, funding rates, biomass caps and the economic calculation come from published documents of the municipality of Ilsfeld. For binding funding conditions the directive itself is authoritative. The source documents are in German.

Funding conditions change. The figures given here reflect the state documented in the case study and are no substitute for funding advice; the directive in force at the time is what binds.

Planning a system and want solid operating data instead of assumptions – measured from the start? Send me a message – the first conversation is free.